Blog Archive

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Cartesian max norm – universal Lipschitz constant for Newtonian gravity

Cartesian max norm – universal Lipschitz constant for Newtonian gravity

Let's consider N bodies. We do not know their exact masses, but we can estimate a maximum value M for each of them.

Let's define cubic volumes (side length 2d) around these bodies, with sides parallel to the Cartesian axes. These are like "safe exclusion zones", in the sense that we assume, somehow, that we know that  the asteroids remain outside all these cubes.

For the exact Newtonian gravitational field generated by these bodies, we have three related mathematical results.

The important point is that we use the Cartesian maximum norm (the maximum absolute value among the three coordinates), rather than the usual Euclidean norm. The exclusion zones are cubes rather than spheres.

Let's define:

delta_g = max(|gx(P)-gx(Q)|, |gy(P)-gy(Q)|, |gz(P)-gz(Q)|)

delta_pos = max(|Px-Qx|, |Py-Qy|, |Pz-Qz|)

where gx, gy, gz are the Cartesian components of gravitational acceleration, and Px, Py, Pz are the coordinates of P (similarly for Q).

1. Local sensitivity for N=1 (sharp)

Let's first consider a single body of mass m.

For an infinitesimally small movement of the observation point outside its excluded cube, the change in gravitational acceleration is bounded, to first order, by:

delta_g <= (G * m * C3 / d^3) * delta_pos

where G is the gravitational constant and C3 is approximately 2.57756.

The coefficient C3 is optimal (or "sharp"), meaning that no smaller constant would work for all admissible positions.

Note that if we had worked with the Euclidean norm and spherical exclusion zones, the value of the constant would have been 2, because the maximum local derivative of the gravitational field is along the radial direction.

2. Local sensitivity for N bodies

If we consider N bodies, with each mass not greater than M, the total gravitational field is the sum of the individual fields.

We obtain the upper bound:

delta_g <= (N * G * M * C3 / d^3) * delta_pos

This bound is valid for infinitesimally small movements of the observation point outside all the excluded cubes, assuming the masses and positions of the N bodies are fixed.

The coefficient is also optimal when considering all possible configurations, although for a particular configuration of N bodies the bound may be conservative.

Note again that, if we had worked with the Euclidean norm and spherical exclusion zones, the value of the sharp local constant would have been 2.

3. Global sensitivity for N bodies

Furthermore, the interesting result is that exactly the same inequality holds globally, for ANY two points P and Q outside all the excluded cubes, no matter how far apart they are:

delta_g <= (N * G * M * C3 / d^3) * delta_pos

This remains true even if the straight line between P and Q crosses one of the excluded cubes.

The coefficient C3 is still optimal in this global case, in the sense that no smaller coefficient would work universally. However, for a particular configuration of N bodies, the bound may be conservative.

Note: if we had worked with the Euclidean norm and spherical exclusion zones, I believe the constant is also 2 globally, but I have not formally verified that case.

The point here is the Cartesian maximum norm and the cubic exclusion zones, especially the global result.

Possible practical interest ?

Is this just a mathematical curiosity, or could it be interesting for numerical methods that divide space into small cubic cells, perhaps to obtain more reliable bounds on gravitational variations?

The mathematical result has been formally verified in Lean and is registered in the Palomar Registry:

https://palomar-registry.org/entry?id=PALOMAR-2026-11-19-000007&version=1

The related GitHub repository, with the Lean proofs, is here:

https://github.com/alexodas/NewtonianLipschitzOptimality



(471) Papagena -- Discrepancy in DE441 mass estimate

 See this message and the related thread on MPML. Thanks all for the comments and new contributions.

Saturday, August 15, 2026

2014 AS33 and 748805 (2013 XF5)

Nominal Analysis - Objective: minimize nominal velocity.




Covariance clone convergence summary

Run setup:
- Pair mode, 100 covariance clones per target plus nominal.
- 101 samples per target, 10,201 sample cross-combinations.
- Analysis epoch: JD 2461200.5.
- Objective: minimize nominal velocity.
- Nominal sample source: covariance.
- Integrator: REBOUND IAS15 in AU-yr-Msun, initial dt 0.3652564 day (0.001 yr), default IAS15 epsilon.
- Massive bodies: Sun; Mercury, Venus, Earth-Moon, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto barycenters; Ceres, Pallas, and Vesta.
- Test particles: all nominal/covariance-clone samples for the 2 targets; clones are massless and do not perturb the massive bodies or each other.

Window window_1:
- Window center: 19564.000000 yr before analysis epoch.
- Selected best time: 19570.451626 yr before analysis epoch.
- Selected-time JD: -4687032.207266.
- Median relative velocity at selected time: 17.540110 m/s.
- Median distance at selected time: 320,716.143 km.

Distance distribution at selected time:
- Minimum combination at selected time: 4,942.666 km.
- p05 / p16: 33,851.918 / 104,130.595 km.
- Median / p84 / p95: 320,716.143 / 689,440.411 / 897,367.988 km.
- Max: 1,411,826.381 km.
- Nominal at selected time: 12,600.442 km.
- Fractions below thresholds: 1.14% < 10,000 km; 15.31% < 100,000 km; 97.03% < 1,000,000 km.

Relative-velocity distribution at selected time:
- Minimum combination at selected time: 0.061954 m/s.
- p05 / p16: 1.710916 / 5.568755 m/s.
- Median / p84 / p95: 17.540110 / 37.732473 / 49.184678 m/s.
- Max: 77.110485 m/s.
- Nominal at selected time: 0.315716 m/s.
- Fractions below thresholds: 3.02% < 1 m/s; 28.75% < 10 m/s.


Median Analysis - Objective: minimize median velocity.



Covariance clone convergence summary

Run setup:
- Pair mode, 100 covariance clones per target plus nominal.
- 101 samples per target, 10,201 sample cross-combinations.
- Analysis epoch: JD 2461200.5.
- Objective: minimize median velocity.
- Nominal sample source: covariance.
- Integrator: REBOUND IAS15 in AU-yr-Msun, initial dt 0.3652564 day (0.001 yr), default IAS15 epsilon.
- Massive bodies: Sun; Mercury, Venus, Earth-Moon, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto barycenters; Ceres, Pallas, and Vesta.
- Test particles: all nominal/covariance-clone samples for the 2 targets; clones are massless and do not perturb the massive bodies or each other.

Candidate screening:
- A pair qualifies only when distance and relative velocity pass a tier at the same sampled time.
- Physical primary: 748805 (2013 XF5) (largest derived target mass).
- Hill radius: 213.761630 km (derived from primary mass and heliocentric semimajor axis).
- Escape velocity: 0.562674 m/s (derived from primary mass and radius).
- Primary diameter: 1.064167 km (derived from H and geometric albedo).
- Primary mass: 1.262e+12 kg (derived from diameter and assumed spherical bulk density).
- Fixed tiers: strict = 1 R_H and 1 v_esc; ordinary = 5 R_H and 2 v_esc; relaxed = 10 R_H and 4 v_esc.
- Found 213,306 qualifying pair-time rows from 1,386 distinct sample pairs.
- Cross-combinations share clone samples and are not statistically independent.

Window window_1:
- Window center: 19564.000000 yr before analysis epoch.
- Selected best time: 19576.771568 yr before analysis epoch.
- Selected-time JD: -4689340.606703.
- Median relative velocity at selected time: 11.270876 m/s.
- Median distance at selected time: 248,171.516 km.

Distance distribution at selected time:
- Minimum combination at selected time: 1,585.842 km.
- p05 / p16: 17,529.396 / 58,617.398 km.
- Median / p84 / p95: 248,171.516 / 533,663.025 / 678,717.034 km.
- Max: 1,083,590.527 km.
- Nominal at selected time: 47,912.957 km.
- Fractions below thresholds: 2.71% < 10,000 km; 22.30% < 100,000 km; 98.68% < 1,000,000 km.

Relative-velocity distribution at selected time:
- Minimum combination at selected time: 0.242574 m/s.
- p05 / p16: 0.835436 / 2.634319 m/s.
- Median / p84 / p95: 11.270876 / 24.186385 / 30.689984 m/s.
- Max: 48.852710 m/s.
- Nominal at selected time: 2.132417 m/s.
- Fractions below thresholds: 6.08% < 1 m/s; 44.57% < 10 m/s.



Intriguing point (but not a proof of separation):

Simultaneous candidate pairs:
- Distinct qualifying sample pairs: 1,386.
- Strongest class counts: strict=0; ordinary=247; relaxed=1139.
- Leading pairs (lexicographic tier, then sampled distance and velocity):
  - 0-1 samples 62-63: ordinary; representative d=1.055 R_H, v=0.5 v_esc at t=-19614.375 yr.
  - 0-1 samples 62-82: ordinary; representative d=1.178 R_H, v=0.5046 v_esc at t=-19618.125 yr.
  - 0-1 samples 62-94: ordinary; representative d=1.234 R_H, v=0.5025 v_esc at t=-19618.125 yr.
  - 0-1 samples 94-71: ordinary; representative d=1.304 R_H, v=0.5557 v_esc at t=-19640.5 yr.
  - 0-1 samples 87-82: ordinary; representative d=1.323 R_H, v=0.5572 v_esc at t=-19561.4375 yr.
  - 0-1 samples 27-47: ordinary; representative d=1.395 R_H, v=0.6558 v_esc at t=-19546.625 yr.
  - 0-1 samples 96-65: ordinary; representative d=1.609 R_H, v=0.574 v_esc at t=-19640.5 yr.
  - 0-1 samples 52-100: ordinary; representative d=1.694 R_H, v=0.6395 v_esc at t=-19554.25 yr.
  - 0-1 samples 86-18: ordinary; representative d=1.707 R_H, v=0.6011 v_esc at t=-19648 yr.
  - 0-1 samples 9-22: ordinary; representative d=1.885 R_H, v=0.6305 v_esc at t=-19539.125 yr.

The dynamical analysis reveals a small but noteworthy subset of orbital solutions in which the two objects approach one another under remarkably gentle conditions. The most interesting point is therefore not so much the minimum of the median at ~19,577 years ago, but rather the existence of individual covariance realizations that produce simultaneously very slow and very close encounters.

The strongest combination is particularly intriguing:

  • km;
  • m/s;
  • ;
  • ;
  • epoch ≈ 19,614 years before the reference epoch.

Thus, the relative velocity is actually about half of the estimated escape velocity, while the encounter distance misses the Hill sphere by only about 5.5%.


Tuesday, August 11, 2026

251223 (2006 UA211) and 814159 (2008 EM188)

Covariance clone convergence summary: minimize nominal velocity

Run setup:

- Pair mode, 100 covariance clones per target plus nominal.

- 101 samples per target, 10,201 sample cross-combinations.

- Analysis epoch: JD 2461200.5.

- Objective: minimize nominal velocity.

- Nominal sample source: covariance.

- Integrator: REBOUND IAS15 in AU-yr-Msun, initial dt 0.3652564 day (0.001 yr), default IAS15 epsilon.

- Massive bodies: Sun; Mercury, Venus, Earth-Moon, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto barycenters; Ceres, Pallas, and Vesta.

- Test particles: all nominal/covariance-clone samples for the 2 targets; clones are massless and do not perturb the massive bodies or each other.


Window window_1:

- Window center: 2803.000000 yr before analysis epoch.

- Selected best time: 2802.818859 yr before analysis epoch.

- Selected-time JD: 1437452.973716.

- Median relative velocity at selected time: 0.721601 m/s.

- Median distance at selected time: 43,032.279 km.


Distance distribution at selected time:

- Minimum combination at selected time: 22,704.637 km.

- p05 / p16: 23,742.091 / 28,904.316 km.

- Median / p84 / p95: 43,032.279 / 57,237.225 / 66,740.024 km.

- Max: 91,420.166 km.

- Nominal at selected time: 42,504.950 km.

- Fractions below thresholds: 0.00% < 10,000 km; 100.00% < 100,000 km; 100.00% < 1,000,000 km.


Relative-velocity distribution at selected time:

- Minimum combination at selected time: 0.294131 m/s.

- p05 / p16: 0.308852 / 0.359331 m/s.

- Median / p84 / p95: 0.721601 / 1.517238 / 2.105724 m/s.

- Max: 4.090306 m/s.

- Nominal at selected time: 0.526255 m/s.

- Fractions below thresholds: 65.32% < 1 m/s; 100.00% < 10 m/s.





Covariance clone convergence summary: minimize median velocity

Run setup:

- Pair mode, 100 covariance clones per target plus nominal.

- 101 samples per target, 10,201 sample cross-combinations.

- Analysis epoch: JD 2461200.5.

- Objective: minimize median velocity.

- Nominal sample source: covariance.

- Integrator: REBOUND IAS15 in AU-yr-Msun, initial dt 0.3652564 day (0.001 yr), default IAS15 epsilon.

- Massive bodies: Sun; Mercury, Venus, Earth-Moon, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto barycenters; Ceres, Pallas, and Vesta.

- Test particles: all nominal/covariance-clone samples for the 2 targets; clones are massless and do not perturb the massive bodies or each other.


Window window_1:

- Window center: 2803.000000 yr before analysis epoch.

- Selected best time: 2802.813520 yr before analysis epoch.

- Selected-time JD: 1437454.923699.

- Median relative velocity at selected time: 0.720172 m/s.

- Median distance at selected time: 43,035.937 km.


Distance distribution at selected time:

- Minimum combination at selected time: 22,647.707 km.

- p05 / p16: 23,705.650 / 28,868.694 km.

- Median / p84 / p95: 43,035.937 / 57,243.968 / 66,745.529 km.

- Max: 91,420.269 km.

- Nominal at selected time: 42,508.718 km.

- Fractions below thresholds: 0.00% < 10,000 km; 100.00% < 100,000 km; 100.00% < 1,000,000 km.


Relative-velocity distribution at selected time:

- Minimum combination at selected time: 0.290953 m/s.

- p05 / p16: 0.306359 / 0.357196 m/s.

- Median / p84 / p95: 0.720172 / 1.516254 / 2.106361 m/s.

- Max: 4.089507 m/s.

- Nominal at selected time: 0.526748 m/s.

- Fractions below thresholds: 65.36% < 1 m/s; 100.00% < 10 m/s.



The run using the median objective closely reproduces the nominal-objective result, strengthening the robustness of the convergence.

The low dispersion shows that the nominal solution might not be simply a lucky realization. This agreement is more significant for the relative velocity than for the distance, therefore, the case is intriguing but not conclusive evidence of a common origin.




2018 BM33 and (206673) = 2003 YC111

Covariance clone convergence summary: - Objective: minimize nominal velocity

Prefix: 2018_BM33_2003_YC111_nominal_100

Run setup:

- Pair mode, 100 covariance clones per target plus nominal.

- 101 samples per target, 10,201 sample cross-combinations.

- Analysis epoch: JD 2461200.5.

- Objective: minimize nominal velocity.

- Nominal sample source: covariance.

- Integrator: REBOUND IAS15 in AU-yr-Msun, initial dt 0.3652564 day (0.001 yr), default IAS15 epsilon.

- Massive bodies: Sun; Mercury, Venus, Earth-Moon, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto barycenters; Ceres, Pallas, and Vesta.

- Test particles: all nominal/covariance-clone samples for the 2 targets; clones are massless and do not perturb the massive bodies or each other.


Window window_1:

- Window center: 7536.000000 yr before analysis epoch.

- Selected best time: 7612.261607 yr before analysis epoch.

- Selected-time JD: -319226.770450.

- Median relative velocity at selected time: 4.887196 m/s.

- Median distance at selected time: 119,529.208 km.


Distance distribution at selected time:

- Minimum combination at selected time: 2,990.397 km.

- p05 / p16: 13,314.389 / 45,322.580 km.

- Median / p84 / p95: 119,529.208 / 244,830.568 / 386,701.755 km.

- Max: 603,364.852 km.

- Nominal at selected time: 3,710.267 km.

- Fractions below thresholds: 3.66% < 10,000 km; 40.12% < 100,000 km; 100.00% < 1,000,000 km.


Relative-velocity distribution at selected time:

- Minimum combination at selected time: 0.082308 m/s.

- p05 / p16: 0.547095 / 1.857212 m/s.

- Median / p84 / p95: 4.887196 / 9.988578 / 15.767729 m/s.

- Max: 24.752360 m/s.

- Nominal at selected time: 0.090495 m/s.

- Fractions below thresholds: 9.62% < 1 m/s; 84.04% < 10 m/s.







Covariance clone convergence summary: - Objective: minimize median velocity
Prefix: 2018_BM33_2003_YC111_median_100

Targets from ../ele.txt:
- 2018 BM33 = (2018 BM33)
- 2003 YC111 = 206673 (2003 YC111)

Run setup:
- Pair mode, 100 covariance clones per target plus nominal.
- 101 samples per target, 10,201 sample cross-combinations.
- Analysis epoch: JD 2461200.5.
- Objective: minimize median velocity.
- Nominal sample source: covariance.
- Integrator: REBOUND IAS15 in AU-yr-Msun, initial dt 0.3652564 day (0.001 yr), default IAS15 epsilon.
- Massive bodies: Sun; Mercury, Venus, Earth-Moon, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto barycenters; Ceres, Pallas, and Vesta.
- Test particles: all nominal/covariance-clone samples for the 2 targets; clones are massless and do not perturb the massive bodies or each other.

Window window_1:
- Window center: 7536.000000 yr before analysis epoch.
- Selected best time: 7611.996605 yr before analysis epoch.
- Selected-time JD: -319129.976812.
- Median relative velocity at selected time: 4.872823 m/s.
- Median distance at selected time: 119,286.334 km.

Distance distribution at selected time:
- Minimum combination at selected time: 3,321.845 km.
- p05 / p16: 13,576.038 / 45,314.551 km.
- Median / p84 / p95: 119,286.334 / 243,514.844 / 383,784.754 km.
- Max: 603,663.869 km.
- Nominal at selected time: 3,427.585 km.
- Fractions below thresholds: 3.55% < 10,000 km; 40.29% < 100,000 km; 100.00% < 1,000,000 km.

Relative-velocity distribution at selected time:
- Minimum combination at selected time: 0.098422 m/s.
- p05 / p16: 0.551154 / 1.850749 m/s.
- Median / p84 / p95: 4.872823 / 9.925090 / 15.636750 m/s.
- Max: 24.687983 m/s.
- Nominal at selected time: 0.104006 m/s.
- Fractions below thresholds: 9.43% < 1 m/s; 84.54% < 10 m/s.





Thursday, August 6, 2026

2015 MM64 versus 2019 van Albada (1935 SX1)

This case may deserve further investigation because (2019) van Albada (1935 SX1) is a known binary asteroid with a satellite, as reported  here by Johnston’s Archive and a  photometric study by Vladimir Benishek, Petr Pravec, Russell Durkee, Marek Husarik.

Confirming a genetic relationship with 2015 MM64 would make the system particularly intriguing.

The nominal solutions show a clear convergence epoch broadly supported by the covariance clones. However, at the selected minimum-median-velocity epoch, all clone combinations remain outside van Albada’s Hill sphere and above the local escape-velocity curve. 

Thus, the case is intriguing but remains inconclusive.

 

Simulation details

Covariance clone convergence summary

Run setup:

- Pair mode, 100 covariance clones per target plus nominal.

- 101 samples per target, 10,201 sample cross-combinations.

- Analysis epoch: JD 2461200.5.

- Objective: minimize median velocity.

- Nominal sample source: covariance.

- Integrator: REBOUND IAS15 in AU-yr-Msun, initial dt 0.3652564 day (0.001 yr), default IAS15 epsilon.

- Massive bodies: Sun; Mercury, Venus, Earth-Moon, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto barycenters; Ceres, Pallas, and Vesta.

- Test particles: all nominal/covariance-clone samples for the 2 targets; clones are massless and do not perturb the massive bodies or each other.


Window window_1:

- Window center: 43768.781000 yr before analysis epoch.

- Selected best time: 43768.013514 yr before analysis epoch.

- Selected-time JD: -13525346.551110.

- Median relative velocity at selected time: 9.172443 m/s.

- Median distance at selected time: 168,300.443 km.


Distance distribution at selected time:

- Minimum combination at selected time: 10,143.336 km.

- p05 / p16: 17,042.759 / 53,341.853 km.

- Median / p84 / p95: 168,300.443 / 555,126.540 / 810,551.880 km.

- Max: 1,091,114.734 km.

- Nominal at selected time: 85,208.192 km.

- Fractions below thresholds: 0.00% < 10,000 km; 33.61% < 100,000 km; 99.01% < 1,000,000 km.


Relative-velocity distribution at selected time:

- Minimum combination at selected time: 0.693410 m/s.

- p05 / p16: 0.991334 / 2.770931 m/s.

- Median / p84 / p95: 9.172443 / 29.927771 / 43.668428 m/s.

- Max: 58.722771 m/s.

- Nominal at selected time: 4.752497 m/s.

- Fractions below thresholds: 5.10% < 1 m/s; 52.48% < 10 m/s.



Let's look at the distance and relative velocity distributions at the time when the median relative velocity was minimum:





Let's put together all pair combinations on the same density plot:



Monday, August 3, 2026

2017 VQ75 and 259711 (2003 YL54)

This is a potentially interesting couple.


100 clones + nominals, searching for the time when median relative velocity was lowest


Looking at the time when the median relative velocity was lowest, we can look at its distribution (together with asteroid distance at the same time:



Run setup:

- Pair mode, 100 covariance clones per target plus nominal.

- 101 samples per target, 10,201 sample cross-combinations.

- Analysis epoch: JD 2461000.5.

- Objective: minimize median velocity.

- Nominal sample source: covariance.

- Integrator: REBOUND IAS15 in AU-yr-Msun, initial dt 0.3652564 day (0.001 yr), default IAS15 epsilon.

- Massive bodies: Sun; Mercury, Venus, Earth-Moon, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto barycenters; Ceres, Pallas, and Vesta.

- Test particles: all nominal/covariance-clone samples for the 2 targets; clones are massless and do not perturb the massive bodies or each other.


Window window_1:

- Window center: 9687.860000 yr before analysis epoch.

- Selected best time: 9892.314224 yr before analysis epoch.

- Selected-time JD: -1152230.581058.

- Median relative velocity at selected time: 2.257536 m/s.

- Median distance at selected time: 44,283.075 km.


Distance distribution at selected time:

- Minimum combination at selected time: 2,700.492 km.

- p05 / p16: 4,837.868 / 12,423.673 km.

- Median / p84 / p95: 44,283.075 / 101,901.503 / 138,618.078 km.

- Max: 270,219.283 km.

- Nominal at selected time: 17,529.654 km.

- Fractions below thresholds: 12.49% < 10,000 km; 83.24% < 100,000 km; 100.00% < 1,000,000 km.


Relative-velocity distribution at selected time:

- Minimum combination at selected time: 0.057856 m/s.

- p05 / p16: 0.211032 / 0.627504 m/s.

- Median / p84 / p95: 2.257536 / 5.200980 / 7.098886 m/s.

- Max: 13.758033 m/s.

- Nominal at selected time: 0.814142 m/s.

- Fractions below thresholds: 25.23% < 1 m/s; 99.18% < 10 m/s.